Latest Dublin Prices

Aer Lingus 2.40 0.03 more
BoI 0.29 0.00 more
CRH 22.09 -0.11 more
Glanbia 14.68 0.03 more
Greencore 0.64 -0.02 more
Ind. News 0.12 0.01 more
Ryanair 10.71 0.37 more


Why the rush to low-pay public jobs?

Monday, July 21 15:07:29

If jobs in the private sector are being created in the kinds of numbers the Government tell us, why is there such a scramble for low-paid, low-level jobs in the public sector?

That's a question posed today by noted Irish economist, Dr Dr. Constantin Gurdgiev in the True Economics blog.

He points out that jobs stats and claims have puzzled many in recent months.

"Government claimed variable numbers at different points in time, ranging between jobs created at 61,000 to 67,000 and so on. Much analysis has been provided of these claims and other numbers on this blog and many other, often divergent, often close-enough and so forth. All, however, points to the fact that jobs are being added in the economy and that at least some of the declines in unemployment rate are down to new positions being posted and filled," he writes.

But, he says, this raises a hugely surprising question. If private sectors jobs are being created, why is there such a huge surplus of unemployed applying for jobs in the private sector?"

He notes that the public sector jobs being rushed-at are not at the top or even the middle of pay and perks distribution. These are roughly E11 and hour jobs, at the bottom of the career ladder and the recruits face the prospect of higher taxes, lower non-wage benefits, increased workloads (compared to the incumbents and past employees), and prospect of slower career progressions.

"One answer is that for all the changes in employment stats we had over the recent months, we still have huge levels of unemployment and underemployment as the legacy of the crisis. On underemployment side, take the percentages of workers in working less than full-time hours as a share of total employment pool. In Q1 2008, 7.5pc of all workers in employment worked less than 20 hours/week, in Q1 2014 the percentage was 8.1pc. Over the same period of time, pc of workers working 20-29 hours per week rose from 10.9pc to 12.8pc, percentage working 30-34 hours per week rose from 4.3pc to 4.5pc. Percentage of workers working more than 35 hours per week dropped from 66.4pc to 61.9pc. Counting in those working less than full-time hours and those on variable hours, 38.1pc of our employment pool are not in full-time employment against 33.6pc back in Q1 2008."

In Q1 2008, there were 113,600 individuals who considered themselves underemployed, in Q1 2014 the number was 258,100. And there are 46,500 more people who are working part-time and consider themselves underemployed today compared to Q3 2008 (earliest we have data for), while numbers of working-age adults not in the labour-force are still up 121,300 on Q1 2008.

"And in the core age categories, applying for these jobs, the percentage of 15-24 year old unemployed relative to total population of that age group was 9.58pc in Q1 2008. This stood at 25.31pc in Q1 2014," Dr Gurdgiev wrote.

"In other words, it is easy to forget that things are still very ugly when it comes to employment situation in Ireland."

For more visit: